Donlin Gold Project, environmental impact statement, final scoping report

Submitted to: US Army Corps of Engineers, Alaska District ; prepared by URS Alaska, LLC.
JBER, AK : CEPOA-RD, [2013]

Appendix E, Public scoping comments.



The Final scoping report is part of Appendix B to:

Donlin Gold Project, draft environmental impact statement / US Army Corps of Engineers.

Publisher:   JBER, AK : CEPOA-RD, [2015]


Appendices E and F of the Final scoping report were not published in print.   (There are "placeholder" pages for those appendices in Volume 7, which is the volume containing Appendices A and B of the full Draft EIS).   These two appendices are available only in digital format, and appear on the Donlin Gold Project EIS background documents webpage as .zip files (190.8 MB and 15.7 MB in size).   They do not appear on the DVD version.

ARLIS has made these appendices available as .pdf files on its website.   The complete text of volume 7 (minus these two appendices) is available on ARLIS's Draft environmental impact statement webpage.   Due to the number of component documents, Appendices E and F are available on separate webpages.   Appendix E appears on this page, while Appendix F is on another page.



LINKS VIA ARLIS DOCUMENT SERVER:

Meeting Transcripts

Meeting LocationDate
AkiakJanuary 31, 2013
AnchorageJanuary 22, 2013
AniakJanuary 15, 2013
BethelJanuary 14, 2013
Crooked CreekJanuary 16, 2013
EmmonakMarch 14, 2013
Holy CrossMarch 20, 2013
Hooper BayFebruary 26, 2013
KipnukMarch 22, 2013
McGrathFebruary 15, 2013
NunapitchukJanuary 30, 2013
QuinhagakFebruary 28, 2013
St. Mary'sMarch 13, 2013
ToksookFebruary 27, 2013


Informal Meeting Notes

AgencyDate
AVCPJanuary 28, 2013
Kuskokwim River Watershed Council (KRWC) RepresentativesJanuary 29, 2013
Orutsarmiut Native Council (ONC) RepresentativesJanuary 28, 2013
U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) January 29, 2013


Comments From Persons

Comments
Alexia, Lisa
Alexie, Nicholai
Alles, Kerry
Andrew, Ignatius Louie
Andrew, Jimmy
Andrews, Shelly
Angellan, Max
Anonymous 1
Anonymous 2
Anonymous 3
Anonymous 4
Anonymous 5
Anonymous 6
Atchison, Anna
Baldwin, Joseph
Beaver, Jimmy
Binkley, John and Judy
Birch, Jerry
Bridewell, Bruce
Brune, Jason
Bruno, Jeff -- This file is corrupt and is not accessible online at this time.
Carey, Maureen
Carlson, Roy
Chavez, Roberta
Collins, Ray
Connelly, Stephen
Daniel, David
Deardorff, Ken
Denton, Steve
Donhauser, Louise -- ARLIS removed 13 pages from this comment containing personal information.
Douglas, Hector
Eaton, Barbara
Eckert, Chris
Eisai, Dan
Engles, Deb
Epchook, Boris -- Mayor of the City of Kwethluk
Esai, Jacqueline
Esai, Philip and Dora
Fagnani, Laurie
Fairbanks, Grant
Ffithian, Cody
Fithian, Heith
Fithian, Sarah
Foster, Jesse
Frederickson, Rick
Gerondale, Chris
Giese, Mark
Gohlke, Karl
Gray, John
Greenfield, Kevin
Grey, Howard
Grifka, Clair
Harbour, Dave
Hawk, Mari
Hayes, Cory
Heatwole, Mike
Hemmen, Rob
Houle, Larry
Ivan, Richard
Jesperson, Michael
John, Darrel
Krause, Terry
Kukowski, Raymond
Larsen, Sabrina
Lefferts, Brian
Long, Becky
Lupie, Ryan
Melzo, Kevin
Miller, Mike
Morgan, Joli
Moses, Peter
Nicolai, Elsie
Nicolai, Yakov, Fr.
Nicholai, Martin
Paul, Jimmy
Percy, Steve
Pollock, Helen
Pollock, Nicholas
Polonowski, John
Runkle, John
Sailer, Randy
Samson, Deborah
Sattler, Mary
Sattler, Maria
Selvik, Justin
Sharp, Minnie
Shelton, Anthony
Shively, John
Stemp, Marc
Stevens, Carolyn
Stevens, Donald
Stevens, Jimmy P., Sr.
St. George, Phil
Thomas, Evelyn
Van Nieuwenhuyse, Rick
Van Wyck, Nicholas
Wallace, John
Williams, Meta
Wilmarth, Larry
Wittenkeller, Sharon
Zemba, Karen


Comments From Agencies

AgencyNotes
Alaska Miners Association (AMA)
Alaska State Chamber of Commerce
Alaska Professional Hunters Association (APHA)
Association of Village Council Presidents (AVCP), Cultural and Environmental Sciences
Borell Consulting Services LLC
Bureau of Land Management (BLM), Anchorage Field Office, Anchorage, Alaska
Calista Corporation
Center for Science in Public Participation

Email messages from David Chambers to Don P. Kuhle (U.S. Army Corps of Engineers), March 29, 2013

Georgetown Tribal Council, Native Village of GeorgetownThis document contains the following:
  • Scoping Comments : Donline Gold Proposed Project   --   7 pages
  • Resolution 13-02   --   March 29, 2013.   2 pages
Center for Water AdvocacySubmitted on behalf of:
  • Center for Water Advocacy
  • Alaska's Big Village Network
  • Federal Land Use Planning Commission
  • Alaska Inter-Tribal Council
Chuathbaluk Traditional CouncilSubmitted on behalf of:   Native Village of Chauthbaluk by the Chauthbaluk Traditional Council
Donlin Gold LLCComment letter from Stan Foo, President & General Manager of Donlin Gold, to Don Kuhle, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.   March 29, 2013
Donlin Gold Working Group (DGWG)
EarthjusticeSubmitted on behalf of:
  • Alaska's Big Village Network
  • Alaska Community Action On Toxics
  • Alaskans For Responsible Mining
  • Alaska Inter-Tribal Council
  • Center For Water Advocacy
  • Cook Inletkeeper
  • Earthworks
  • Grant Fairbanks
  • Ground Truth Trekking
  • Northern Alaska Environmental Center
  • Orutsararmiut Native Council
This 24-page comment letter is preceded by transmittal sheets (three pages of email messages).
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Region 10
Georgetown Tribal Council, Native Village of GeorgetownThis document contains the following:
  • Scoping Comments : Donline Gold Proposed Project   --   7 pages
  • Resolution 13-02   --   March 29, 2013.   2 pages
Kiewit Infrastructure West Co.
Knik Tribal Council
Kuskokwim River Watershed Council (KRWC)
Kwethluk Incorporated
Millrock Resources
NANA Regional Corporation, Inc.
Native Village of Napaimute
Perrin's Rainy Pass Lodge, LLC.
Port of BethelFrom Peter A. Williams, Port Director
Resisting Environmental Destruction on Indigenous Lands (REDOIL)
Resource Development Council for Alaska, Inc. (RDC)Testimony of Marleanna Hall, Projects Coordinator, Resource Development Council Donlin Gold EIS Scoping Meeting.   Tuesday, January 22, 2013, Anchorage, Alaska
Resource Development Council for Alaska, Inc. (RDC)Comments submitted by Marleanna Hall, Projects Coordinator
Taiga Resources Conservation
U.S. Department of the Interior, Fish and Wildlife Service, Anchorage Fish and Wildlife Field Office
Village of Lower Kalskag Tribe
Yukon-Kuskokwim Health Corporation


Donlin Documents

ContentsNotes
List of Contents
Donlin NewslettersDonlin Creek Project updates and Donlin newsletters, 2005-2013.   File size: 68 MB
Newsletter Distribution Information
Donlin Gold Project SummaryDonlin Gold Project Description Booklet (2012). Text in English
Donlin Creek Mine: Caliarkam TangrruarutiiDonlin Project Description Booklet (2008). Text in Yup'ik
Donlin Gold Website ScreenshotsPDF from website
Planning Your Future: Jobs With Donlin GoldDonlin Gold Jobs Booklet (2012)


Supporting Documents

Agency / Person ResponsibleTitle / Notes
Alaska's Big Village Network ; Alaska Community Action on Toxins ; Alaskans for Responsible Mining ; Alaska Inter-Tribal Council ; Cook Inletkeeper ; Earthworks Action ; Ground Truth Trekking ; Southeast Alaska Conservation Council ; Newtok Traditional Council ; Northern Alaska Envrionmental Center ; The Center for Water AdvocacyCorrespondence to Michelle Bonnet, Director, Division of Water, Department of Environmental Conservation
Bethel City CouncilCity of Bethel, Alaska, Resolution #12-12: A Resolution by the Bethel City Council Requesting Special Consideration of Mercury Management for Mining Operations Along the Kuskokwim River Watershed
Bonnet, Michelle (Director, Division of Water, Department of Environmental Conservation)Correspondence to Pete Dronkers, Director, Clean Water & Mining Program, Northern Alaska Environmental Center
Booz Allen & Hamilton, Inc. -- For U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Region 9Draft - Mercury Mass Balance and Emissions Factor Estimates for Gold Ore Processing Facilities.   January 14, 2001
Chambers, David M.A Position Paper on Perpetual Water Treatment for Mines.   Center for Science in Public Participation. June 2007
Council on Envrionmental Quality, Executive Office of the PresidentEnvironmental Justice: Guidance Under the National Environmental Policy Act.   December 10, 1997
Dronkers, Pete (Northern Alaska Environmental Center) Correspondence to Ms. Lynn Tomich Kent, Deputy Commissioner, Department of Environmental Conservation
Eckley, C.S. ; Gustin, M. ; Marsik, F. ; Miller, M.B.Measurement of Surface Mercury Fluxes at Active Industrial Gold Mines in Nevada (USA).   In: Science of the Total Environment, vol. 409 (2011), pages 514-522.   ARLIS is not posting this journal article online due to copyright restrictions.
Ecology and Environment, Inc. -- For U.S. Department of [the] Interior, Bureau of Land ManagementDraft Remedial Investigation Report, Red Devil Mine, Alaska.  March 2012
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants : Gold Mine Ore Processing and Production Area Source Category; and Addition to Source Category List for Standards. Final rule, February 17, 2011.   In: Federal Register, vol. 76, no. 33 (February 17, 2011), pages 9450-9489.
National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants: Gold Mine Ore Processing and Production Area Source Category and Addition to Source Category List for Standards. Proposed rule, April 28, 2010.   In: Federal Register, vol. 75, no. 81 (April 28, 2010), pages 22470- 22496.
Ore Mining and Dressing Point Source Category Effluent Limitations Guidelines and New Source Performance Standards.   In: Federal Register, vol. 47 (December 3, 1982), pages 54598-54621.
Technical Fact Sheet on Mercury
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), Climate Change Division, Office of Atmospheric ProgramsTechnical Support Document for Endangerment and Cause or Contribute Findings for Greenhouse Gases under Section 202(a) of the Clean Air Act.   December 7, 2009
Envrionmental Protection Agency (EPA), Pacific Southwest, Region 9Carson River Mercury Site   (PDF of webpage)
Fall, James A. ; Caylor, David ; Coffing, Michael ; Davis, Brian L. ; Georgette, Susan ; Wheeler, PollyAlaska Subsistence Fisheries 1999 Annual Report. Alaska Department of Fish and Game. (Technical paper ; no. 300)
Joint Munitions CommandInformation Sheet : HWAD Mercury Consolidation Project.   July 29, 2010
Matz, Angela -- For Bureau of Land Management, Alaska State OfficeMercury, Arsenic, and Antimony in Aquatic Biota from the Middle Kuskokwim River Region, Alaska, 2010-2011: Interim Report.   November 29, 2012
Miller, Matthieu B. ; Gustin, Mae S.Testing and Modeling the Influence of Reclamation and Control Methods for Reducing Non-point Mercury Emissions Associated with Industrial Open Pit Gold Mines.   In: Journal of the Air & Waste Management Association, vol. 12 (March 2013).   ARLIS is not posting this journal article online due to copyright restrictions.
Nevada Division of Environmental Protection, Bureau of Air Pollution Control (NDEP)In the Matter of: Queenstake Resources USA, Inc. -- Jerritt Canyon Mine, Elko County, Nevada (FIN A00004) : Notice of Findings and Order No. 2008-13
Oak Ridge National Laboratory -- For U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Environmental ManagementU.S. Department of Energy Interim Guidance on Packaging, Transportation, Receipt, Management, and Long-Term Storage of Elemental Mercury
President of the United States of America Executive Order 12898.   In: Federal Register, vol. 59, no. 32 (February 16, 1994)
Presidential Memorandum : Executive Order 12898
Resisting Environmental Destruction On Indigenous Lands (REDOIL) ; Alaska Community Action on Toxics (ACAT)Mining and Toxic Metals: A Case Study of the Proposed Donlin Creek Mine
Stillwater Mining Company, Northern Plains Resource Council, Cottonwood Resource Council, Stillwater Protective AssociationGood Neighbor Agreement Between Stillwater Mining Company and Northern Plains Resource Council, Cottonwood Resource Council, Stillwater Protective Association.   Amended November 11, 2009
U.S. Department of Labor, Mine Safety and Health Administration (MSHA) Controlling Mercury Hazards in Gold Mining: A Best Practices Toolbox.   Draft September 1997
Utah Department of Health and Utah Division of Wildlife Resources (UDWR)Utah Waterfowl Advisories (this link displays a screenshot of the first page of the website in PDF format). This resource was used as supporting documentation by the perparers of the draft environmental impact statement.To consult this resource further, go to http://waterfowladvisories.utah.gov/ (note that the current display differs from the earlier screenshot).
Williams, David R.Climate Change - Extreme Conditions: Do Plans of Operations Need to Include an Ark?   20th Annual Mine Design, Operations & Closure Conference April 29 - May 3, 2012. Bureau of Land Management, Butte, MT